Back to blogs

    Close the month on a freight accrual you can defend

    By TransportOne Editorial Team•November 20, 2026•7 min read
    Hands working a desk calculator beside a laptop showing an accounting ledger screen.

    October closed with a freight accrual of 1.4 million dollars. By mid-January the invoices have landed, the true-up runs 190,000 against you, and someone upstairs is asking how a figure you produce every single month comes out that far off.

    A freight accrual is your estimate of the transportation you consumed in the period but haven't been billed for yet. It's only as good as whatever you built it from, and most teams build it from a source that doesn't know what the shipment cost.

    Where the accrual number actually comes from

    Take apart the workpaper behind any month-end freight number and it traces back to one of three places.

    SourceWhat it representsWhere it fails
    Carrier invoices received before cutoffWhat the carrier is claimingCarries every overcharge the audit hasn't caught yet
    Planned or tendered cost from the TMSWhat you expected when the load went outNo accessorials, no reweigh, no reclass, and fuel priced at whatever index week the tender used
    Audited expected cost per loadContract rate applied to what actually shipped, plus the accessorials the execution record supportsNeeds shipment events and a rating engine wired together, which most finance teams don't have

    The third one is the right answer and the hardest to stand up. The first deserves a closer look, because it's the most common and the most wrong.

    Accruing off the carrier's bill books the carrier's position

    An unaudited invoice records what the carrier has asked for. That's a different number from what the move cost you, and the gap between them is the whole reason the audit exists. Accrue from the invoice and you book a detention charge the driver didn't earn, a reclass the NMFC doesn't support, and a fuel line computed on the wrong week. Your analyst then wins the dispute in February, the credit posts in February, and a month that shipped none of that freight gets the benefit.

    Controllers go along with it because an invoice is a document and an internal estimate feels like a guess. That instinct is backwards here: the estimate is built from your contract and your gate times, and the invoice is built from the carrier's. The same reflex sits underneath the standard AP match, which is why three-way matching was built for purchase orders and keeps falling over on freight.

    The charges that arrive after you've closed

    Detention, lumper reimbursement, reweigh, reclass, redelivery, TONU and layover don't exist at tender, and they rarely travel with the linehaul bill. They arrive on their own schedule, which is longer than most accrual policies assume.

    Under 49 U.S.C. 13710(a)(3), a motor carrier that wants to collect charges beyond what it originally billed has to issue that bill within 180 days of your receipt of the original bill, and you have 180 days from receipt to contest a bill. A September pickup can produce a brand new, perfectly collectible charge in March. Nothing in your TMS predicted it.

    Ocean runs tighter and still crosses a close. The FMC's demurrage and detention billing rule, in force since 28 May 2024, requires a vessel operator or marine terminal to issue its invoice within 30 calendar days of when the charges were last incurred, and gives the billed party at least 30 calendar days to ask for mitigation, refund or waiver. A container that starts burning demurrage on 28 October can be invoiced lawfully on 25 November, and it is an October cost. If your ocean accrual is built from the booking, there's no line in it for that container.

    The accrual that never clears

    Every received-not-invoiced balance carries a tail of loads that were accrued and never billed. The carrier lost the paperwork, the account moved to a factoring company mid-stream, or the charges got absorbed into a consolidated bill nobody matched. The line then sits there for a year until someone writes it off in a cleanup, and that write-off lands in whatever month the cleanup happened. The original period stays overstated and an unrelated one picks up the credit. Age the RNI balance by load and look hard at anything past 180 days, since after that window a motor carrier mostly can't come back for it.

    Fuel surcharge moves while you're closing the books

    Most domestic fuel surcharge tables key off the EIA's weekly retail on-highway diesel average, published Monday afternoons and applied by pickup week. Accrue fuel at a flat cents-per-mile figure, or at last quarter's average, and you book a number that was right a few weeks ago.

    The EIA's national average was 6.292 dollars a gallon on 2 November 2026, 6.127 on 9 November, and 5.937 on 16 November. Call it 35.5 cents inside two weeks. On a table that adds a cent per mile for every six cents of diesel above the peg, that's about six cents per mile, roughly 59 dollars on a 1,000 mile dry van run. Run a few thousand loads a month and the fuel line on its own accounts for a chunk of the miss that usually gets blamed on accessorials.

    LTL tables generally work off a percentage of linehaul instead, and intermodal and ocean bunker adjustments publish on their own cycles. One blended fuel assumption across all of them won't survive contact with the invoices. The mechanics are in how a fuel surcharge is four calculations, not one line item.

    Building the freight accrual from the audit

    The accrual and the pre-payment audit are the same calculation run at two different moments. Both ask what a load should cost under the contract given what actually happened to it. Automated freight invoice audit already produces that figure per load before payment, so pushing it into the GL is a reporting decision rather than a second project. Manufacturers absorbing inbound freight into standard cost feel it first, since a late true-up moves product margin rather than one freight line. That's usually where freight audit for manufacturers starts.

    Sort open loads into four buckets at cutoff and the entry falls out of them:

    • Delivered, invoiced and audited. Use the audited amount. That's actual cost, and it doesn't belong in the accrual at all.
    • Delivered, not yet invoiced. Accrue the expected cost: contract linehaul on the actual weight, class and stop count, plus every accessorial the execution record already supports.
    • In transit at cutoff. Accrue the portion performed, on whatever basis your policy already uses for partial performance.
    • Tendered and cancelled. Accrue TONU where the carrier arrived and got turned, nothing where it didn't.

    The second bucket is where shipment exception tracking pays for itself. Arrival and departure timestamps mean detention earned on 29 October is in the October accrual on 29 October, instead of appearing six weeks later as a surprise on a carrier's balance-due bill.

    What gets posted

    Debit freight expense at the cost centre and lane that earned it, credit accrued freight, reverse on day one of the next period. Keep the accrual at load granularity rather than rolling it into a monthly pool. When the invoice arrives you clear that specific load, the RNI balance ages per load, and stale lines announce themselves. A pooled accrual hides its own errors, because any single invoice can disappear into it and nobody notices the match never happened.

    Stop reporting accrual accuracy as a net number

    Net accrual variance is a vanity metric, and most freight scorecards still lead with it. Over-accrue linehaul by 40,000 dollars, under-accrue accessorials by 38,000, and the deck says you missed by 2,000 while both estimates are broken. Take absolute values before summing, then split the variance by charge code and by carrier. The split is the part worth reading: a persistent miss on one carrier's detention line is a timestamp problem, while a miss spread evenly across linehaul is a rate table that drifted behind the contract that replaced it.

    A test to run on your next close

    Pull the true-up journals from your last two closes, split every line by charge code, take absolute values, sum, and rank. Detention and demurrage at the top means your event data is the problem rather than your accrual method, and linehaul at the top usually means a rate table went stale. A fuel line at the top is nearly always a disagreement about which index week a carrier applies, and you can settle that one with an email to its pricing desk.

    If you want to see what your own close looks like built from audited expected cost, book a walkthrough and bring one month of freight invoices alongside the accrual workpaper that went with them. The gap between those two documents is usually the whole conversation.

    Frequently asked questions

    What is a freight accrual?
    It's the liability you book at period end for transportation services you've already consumed but haven't been invoiced for. The debit hits freight expense or inventory depending on whether the freight is inbound and absorbed into cost, and the credit sits in an accrued freight or received-not-invoiced account. It reverses at the start of the next period, and the carrier's invoice then clears it.
    How do you calculate a freight accrual at month-end?
    Take every load with a service date inside the period that has no audited invoice against it, and price each one at the contract rate using what actually shipped: real weight, real class, real stop count, real equipment. Add the accessorials the execution record already supports, such as detention backed by gate timestamps or a lumper fee backed by a receipt. Price fuel at the index week the contract says applies, not a blended average. Post at load granularity so each line clears against its own invoice.
    How long after delivery can a carrier still bill you for extra charges?
    For motor carriers, 49 U.S.C. 13710(a)(3) requires a bill for charges beyond those originally billed to be issued within 180 days of your receipt of the original bill, and gives you 180 days from receipt to contest a bill. Ocean demurrage and detention is tighter: under the FMC's billing rule effective 28 May 2024, the invoice has to be issued within 30 calendar days of when the charges were last incurred. Either window can easily cross a month-end or a quarter-end.
    Why is our freight accrual always wrong on accessorials?
    Because accessorials aren't in the tender. A TMS planned cost knows the lane, the weight and the equipment, and knows nothing about the two hours the driver waited at the consignee or the reweigh the carrier ran at the terminal. If the accrual is built from planned cost, every accessorial is a true-up by construction. Accruing from execution events, rather than from the tender or the carrier's later bill, is what closes that gap.

    See it on your freight

    Stop Overpaying On Freight Invoices

    Penny checks every invoice against your contracts and what the shipment actually did, then disputes what doesn’t hold up. You pay 30% of what she saves you, and nothing if she saves nothing.

    See how Penny works

    Found this useful? Share it with your team.

    Share on LinkedIn